As an Investment Advisor, I am wrapped-up in the daily ups and downs of the stock and bond markets, or am worrying about inflation, deflation or just “flation” – either “in” or “de” or “stag” or “re.”
I constantly ponder questions like “What types of stocks will do better – large companies, small companies, domestic or international?” And “What direction are the markets headed in?”
For some silly reason, I always think that most Americans are thinking about this stuff too. I forget that this is what I do for a living and that most people don’t think about this very much. And they shouldn’t.
Most people get their financial news by catching snippets from newspapers, websites, radio, watching guys like Jim Cramer on CNBC at the gym, or by listening to my show or reading my blog (hint, hint – blog.slpomeranz.com.)
Technical Analysis
So, while I have your attention, allow me to acquaint you with two “technical” views on where the market is headed.
By the way, Technical Analysis is simply looking for patterns and trends in financial data to glean “insights” – really just guesses – on where the markets may be headed next.
Truth is, no one really knows where the markets are headed. But markets do trade on technical analysis – sort of like the tail wagging the dog – making some of it a self-fulfilling prophecy, till some cataclysmic “real” event washes away all theories. Sort of like the dot-com bust or the mortgage market collapse where reality ultimately trumps theory.
Two Technical Views on Market Direction
The two technical analysts I follow are Lowry onDemand and Hedgeye.
On the one hand, Lowry sees bullish patterns in the data. Here’s an excerpt from last Friday’s market commentary:
“… any period of weakness should probably be viewed as an opportunity to add to equity positions. Investors might find this a good time to look for stocks with strong technical ratings in strong sectors and groups.”
You can sense that Lowry does not believe we are headed for another nasty downturn.
Hedgeye doesn’t agree. While Hedgeye analyzes technicals, they also closely follow the state of the US and world economies. Here’s the gist, in my words, of what Hedgeye principal analyst, Howard Penney, sees:
“… a weakening labor market, softening consumer confidence, softening housing activity and retail sales, and an intensifying trade deficit – the early stages of a renewed economic decline.”
Summary
While Lowry sees no near-term threats, Hedgeye believes another downturn is just around the corner. So there you have it, diametrically opposite views from fairly intelligent people. Welcome to my hell!
The bottom-line is, how important are their predictions for the short-term? The answer is: not very… because short-term market movements are not all that important.
The point is, many companies will create wealth over time so maintaining the assets you have in the market and adding during market dips should suit you well.
By the way, most money managers and so-called stock market experts fare no better than you when it comes to picking winning stocks. So listen to all commentators with a grain of salt. We may sound confident, like we know what the future holds, but alas we do not!
Building a portfolio based on trying to foretell the future will always lead to disaster. Generally speaking, buy good quality stocks, diversify, and let it ride.






By now, many of my listeners and readers are familiar with the intellectual challenge, exhilaration, exasperation and confusion in my line of work – this devilish work which I embrace most wholeheartedly. When I try to make sense of my friend and nemesis, the market – there are six-metrics I can turn to. With the help of Jacob Wolinsky, I present them to you.
1. P/ E-TTM Ratio which is the market’s index price (P) divided by its earnings per share for the past or trailing twelve months (E-TTM.) This ratio is currently at 18.3 for the market as a whole – slightly higher than the 17.2 reading last month and suggests the market may be slightly overvalued.
2. P/E-10 Year Ratio uses average earnings per share over the past 10 years to smooth out fluctuations due to unexpected events such as say 9/11. This ratio is currently at 20.5 and indicates that the market may be overvalued.
3. Dividend Yield is the ratio of the S&P 500’s annual dividends to its index price. The average dividend yield for stocks is currently at 1.99%, lower than 2.13% from last month.
Dividend Ratios have shown to be an unreliable indicator of market valuations, but we keep an eye on them anyway.
4. Price / Book-Value (P/BV) currently averages 2.09, marginally below the 2.11 This is well below the 30-year average of 2.41 for the S&P 500 – suggesting that the market may be slightly undervalued.
Note: Legendary investor Martin Whitman believes P/BV is a better measure of value than P/E because book values are harder to fudge than earnings, and are less affected by near-term economic cycles.
5. Total Market Capitalization / GDP ratio currently stands at 78.7%, higher than 73.4% last month. This ratio has historically ranged between 35% in 1982 and 148% in 2000.
Note: Warren Buffett believes that this ratio is “probably the best single measure of where valuations stand at any given moment” and investing website, GuruFocus, predicts that based on current levels for this ratio, the market should return about 6.5% in the coming year.
6. Tobin’s Q is the ratio of market capitalization to the replacement value of all of the company’s assets. Q is currently at 0.98 compared to 0.92 last month and an average of 0.72 over the past several decades. Some estimate that the market may be over-valued by 39% based on Tobin’s Q.
To recap, the measures are mixed. 3 suggest over-valuation, 1 fair-value and 1 undervalued.
Based on my decades of experience analyzing such valuation ratios, I believe the market is moderately overvalued at current levels. These levels would suggest single digit market performance over the next 5-7 years, and predict that returns will at least meet or beat inflation, but not offer the high returns we have come to expect.
Leave a Comment
Posted in On The Money! Commentary | Tags: market, stock market, annual dividens, earnings, warren buffett, expense, P /E TTM Ratio, P /E Year Ratio, dividend Yield, Price, book value, P/BV, total market capitalization, GDP, ratio, index, index price, market index price, yield, stock yield, average dividend, dividend ratios, market valuations, average, Martin Whitman, measure of value, economic cycles, fair value, over-valuation, undervalued, Tobin's Q